 |
Speaking
of Sports
by Alex
Prasad
|
Sorry
Cinderella:
Why Hoosiers Can’t Happen in Michigan
March 7, 2010
This past
week was Spring Break for students at
Eastern Michigan
and Michigan. Some traveled to tropical destinations, some
went on service trips, and some came home. I found myself
spending a tropical (what great weather this past week!)
week in Novi, catching up on homework and seeing a few old
friends I haven’t seen in a long time.
I also got
a chance to take in a
Novi hockey game, specifically their 11-3 shellacking of the
Walled Lake Northern Knights. The
Novi student section was energetic and it was hard not to be,
with its team so easily crushing the competition.
Over the last couple years I’ve traveled to countless
sporting events on no less than 20 college campuses. It’s
rare I hear a chant that’s new
AND
comedic, but with Novi up handily midway through the second
period, the
Novi student
section began a fantastic heckle.
Yelling
towards the Walled Lake Northern fans, they chanted, “We
can’t hear you (clap, clap, clap clap clap), repeat, we’ll
cheer for you, repeat, let’s go Northern”. It certainly made
me bust out laughing.
And it was
a great night for
Novi hockey.
They’d go on to defeat Hartland 4-3 Friday, and are set to
face off against Warren De La Salle Tuesday at 6:30 pm at
Novi Ice Arena. The winner of that game heads to Compuware
Ice Arena and the state semi-finals.
Watching
the Novi team dominate Northern - they were bigger, more
physical, faster and controlled the puck for most of the
game - I couldn’t help but wonder what would happen if Novi
and Catholic Central faced off again in the state
semi-finals or finals. How great would that be?!? (CC beat
Novi 6-2 earlier, a regular season game). Well it turns out
the two schools are in different divisions (CC is D1 in
hockey, Novi D2); alas, my dream scenario couldn’t happen.
Hockey,
like basketball and some other sports in Michigan, allow all
teams to qualify for the playoffs. Unlike football where at
least 6 wins are required, even the worst teams in these
sports have a chance at a state title at the end of their
regular seasons. Such egalitarian entrance policies are
designed to give every team a shot, evoking warm and fuzzy
feelings and perhaps flashbacks to one of the best sports
movies of all time,
Hoosiers. But that’s not actually how it works.
In
Hoosiers, literally every team in the state competed in the
same bracket. Michigan, like every other state in the union
today, including tragically Indiana, has separated its
schools by size in each sport into separate divisions.
In cross
country, there are four state championship cross country
teams in November at MIS and there will be 3 state champions
in hockey this year. Why can’t we let the Cinderellas of the
world compete with the private schools that recruit middle
school athletes? Why don’t we make the large public school
of 2,000+ students prove they can beat the small public
schools from up North with 500 kids in grades K-12?
It wouldn’t
be difficult to do: have all the state champions from the
different divisions play for the title of best team in the
state. The MHSAA can keep the multiple state championship
formula and the schools would get to compete for an even
more illustrious prize.
The MHSAA
thinks it would be cruel and unusual to make these underdogs
get crushed annually by the bigger schools. But what if the
small schools pulled off the upset? It happened at least
once before, and became one of the greatest American sports
stories of all time. Surely it can happen again.
Other Recent
Columns:
A new outlet for sports passion
Novi’s Gargantuan Sporting Footprint
The underestimated power of sports
Bernie's farewell
Shamrock radio
Never say never
Previous Columns
Alex Prasad is a life-long
Michigan resident, a student at
the University of Michigan and a 2007 graduate of Novi High
School. He was the Novi.org school and sports reporter
while he was NHS. Alex was also a captain of the NHS Cross
Country Team and Track Team under legendary coach Bob
Smith. His passion for running continues to this day, as he
trains for a marathon.
Alex is currently Sports Director
of WOLV-TV, the student run television station at UM, and
produces shows on both the Michigan Football and Michigan
Hockey teams.
You can see more of his work
here.
|